Wednesday, October 3, 2007

My reaction to Tip #8 - John Garrity

I chose tip number 4 labeled; Retreat from “pay for failure” by making it easier to fire for cause. The activist is right when explaining the fact that firing high officials could come back to bite you in the end. Unlawful firing practices could pose as a huge lawsuit; therefore, this fire for cause is a great idea. If a company decides to fire a high ranking official, an investigation should be done BEFORE the actual termination. If the individual decides not to testify against his or her poor performance for the company they should have no right to even think about suing for unlawful firing. It shouldn’t matter if you want to keep the person who is being fired happy, its worth having somebody mad then costing millions or billions in a settlement case.

My Reaction to Tip # 9 - Kyle Toelken

As I was looking over all of the "Ten ways to restore Investor Confidence in Compensation" the one that caught my eye was number 9. In the ninth tip, the companies talk about doing regular check-ups in their financial department concerning audits and their financial balances. If companies start to look at the problems that other companies are having with internal fraud then they can learn from that to make necessary changes within. Companies are becoming smarter than ever before, they are realizing that the financial well-being of a company rides in the financial department. They are starting to rotate people, so that the auditor isn't always doing the books. This makes it harder for people to find loop holes within a given organization.

My Reaction to Tip #3 - Daniel Attella

I agree that a severance package is not necessary for upper level officials. Typically CEO's, CFO's and other high-ranking officials in an organization hold enough stock in the company to keep them afloat for the rest of their life. For example I had recently heard about Exxon Mobil' CEO Lee Raymond has a retirement package valued over $400 million the largest retirement package in history. Is this necessary? I'm not sure if anyone is worth that much. I think that these CEO's and higher ups can live very well with what they have earned throughout their time as CEO. Stock accumulation is one method, another would be a solid 401K plan, or an IRA, or other sources of investments to keep what they have at the time of retirement in a growth phase.

My reaction to Tip #1- Sandra Adams

By keeping the financial consultants separate from management, it will eliminate a huge conflict of interest. If the financial consultants are working under the management, it will definitely create a biased atmosphere in benefit for the management. The managers are able to manipulate the consultants by threatening their jobs. Putting these two positions separate will show stockholders that their money is not being manipulated into the pockets of managers.

Tuesday, October 2, 2007

Senior Seminar Assignment #7

Read the article "Ten Ways to Restore Investor Confidence in Compensation" in the Wall Street Journal, April 9, 2007.

By 7:00AM on Thursday, October 4, please post your reaction to any one of the 10 tips the article makes to produce executive pay plans acceptable to disgruntled stockholders. Label your entry: My reaction to Tip #_- Your first and last name.

Research tip: In this same edition of the Wall Street Journal you might find information on the 2006 compensation package of the CEO for your group case study. See article, "The Boss's Pay".

Monday, October 1, 2007

Question 5 Ian S

To be paid 52 Million dollars in one year, you are probably guilty for something. Arthur Anderson is on the same level as both Ken Lay and Jeff Skilling. They are all guilty of misleading consumers and stock holders, as well as their staff of thousands. Arthur Anderson is not only guilty, but he helped facilitate in misleading everyone. As the auditor he was suppose to be honest, but was dishonest and allowed pay offs. It was greed that makes him guilty of the crime.

-Ian Stuart

Bishara Etienne Question #5

I believe that Arthur Andersen did not behave ethically. As the auditor he knew what Enron was doing was wrong and the company was not acting in the well being of its shareholders, employees etc. Also if Andersen knew that he was not being ethical because his patner instructed his staff to shred documents relating to the audit of Enron. I think that Arthur should have overlooked the lucrative payments and do what was morally right, which was to report Enron.